⚠ A Return Flattered by BuybacksLow threat

KLA (KLAC) — threat to the moat

KLA's return on equity is inflated by a shrunken equity base; its return on invested capital, half as high, is the honest measure.

An 87.5% return on equity1 tells an owner less than it seems. KLA's equity was $1,401.4 million at the end of fiscal 2022, after $3,967.8 million of buybacks that year2, and a return on that base would have been enormous whatever the business earned.

Return on equity against return on invested capital (%)ROICROEFY202435.3%87.9%FY202546.3%100.8%FY202646.4%87.5%Moat Explorer calculations from KLA filings; ROIC by the repo method
Return on equity runs at about twice return on capital.

The comparison that matters is with the capital the business uses. Return on invested capital by the repo method was 46.4% in fiscal 20263: still very high, and about half the return on equity.

The gap is the cost of leverage and buybacks, not a flaw. But it means the equity return will fall sharply in any year KLA stops buying back and lets equity rebuild, as it has since fiscal 2022, when equity went from $1,401.4 million to $6,349.8 million45.

Stockanalysis puts KLA's return on invested capital at 66.75%6, higher than the repo method's 46.4%7, because it measures capital differently. The two methods agree on the direction and on the size of the gap to the cost of capital; either figure shows a business earning several times what its capital costs.

The market reads the same distortion. KLA traded at 38.68 times book value on 25 September 20268, a multiple that says more about how little equity is left than about how richly the shares are priced.

Judge the business by return on invested capital. A fall below 35% in a year when revenue grew would be the sign.

References
  1. Moat Explorer calcAn 87.5% return on equity tells an owner less than it seems.
    Moat Explorer calculation from KLA's reported figures ($ millions unless stated; fiscal years end on 30 June; per-share figures adjusted for the ten-for-one split of June 2026). Revenue growth: FY2022 9,211.9 / 6,918.7 - 1 = +33.1%; FY2023 10,496.1 / 9,211.9 - 1 = +13.9%; FY2024 9,812.2 / 10,496.1 - 1 = -6.5%, the only decline FY2015-FY2026; FY2025 12,156.2 / 9,812.2 - 1 = +23.9%; FY2026 13,579.5 / 12,156.2 - 1 = +11.7%; FY2015-FY2026 13,579.5 / 2,814.0 = 4.8 times, 15.4% a year; FY2026 against FY2023 13,579.5 / 10,496.1 - 1 = +29%. Net income FY2024 2,761.9 / 3,387.3 - 1 = -18.5%, a fall of 625.4, of which the 289.5 impairment is 46%; net margin 4,830.8 / 13,579.5 = 35.6%; Other FY2023 381.1 / 259.4 - 1 = +46.9%; gross margin 1,598.8 / 2,814.0 = 56.8% (FY2015), 2,699.5 / 4,568.9 = 59.1% (FY2019); FY2026 4,830.8 / 4,061.6 - 1 = +18.9%; FY2015-FY2026 4,830.8 / 366.2 = 13.2 times; EPS 3.66 / 0.224 = 16.3 times. Operating income (no line reported): gross profit 8,324.4 - R&D 1,532.1 - SG&A 1,131.5 = 5,660.8 (FY2026), 5,660.8 / 13,579.5 = 41.7%; interest cover 5,660.8 / 284.4 = about 20 times. Segments FY2026: Semiconductor Process Control 12,244.7 / 13,579.5 = 90.2% of revenue; segment gross profit 12,244.7 - 4,453.6 = 7,791.1, 7,791.1 / 12,244.7 = 63.6%; segment profit 5,482.8 / 12,244.7 = 44.8%; 5,482.8 / 5,655.4 = 96.9% of segment profit; Specialty Semiconductor Process 64.6 / 584.1 = 11.1%, gross 278.8 / 584.1 = 47.7% (FY2021 206.7 / 369.2 = 56.0%); PCB and Component Inspection 108.0 / 750.4 = 14.4%, gross 385.3 / 750.4 = 51.3% (FY2024 159.0 / 552.5 = 28.8%); smaller segments 64.6 + 108.0 = 172.6; SSP segment gross margin FY2022 242.5 / 456.6 = 53.1%, FY2023 281.9 / 543.4 = 51.9%, FY2024 282.9 / 528.7 = 53.5%, FY2025 303.9 / 587.1 = 51.8%; Orbotech segments revenue less product categories 1,334.5 - (502.5 + 460.3) = 371.7; process control share of research 1,341.3 / 1,532.1 = 87.5%, almost nine-tenths; SG&A 1,131.5 / 13,579.5 = 8.3%; segment revenue 584.1 + 750.4 = 1,334.5. Process control segment research 1,341.3 / 12,244.7 = 11%; segment revenue growth 12,244.7 / 10,947.4 - 1 = +11.9%; SSP products 502.5 / 584.1 = 86% of segment revenue, research 59.4 / 584.1 = 10%; PCI Q4 241.1 / 750.4 = 32% of the year; process control lines FY2019 (1,630.9 + 1,161.3) / 4,568.9 = 61.1%; patterning within process control lines 2,791.1 / (4,336.7 + 2,791.1) = 39.2% (FY2023), 2,706.8 / (6,630.8 + 2,706.8) = 29.0% (FY2026); services share FY2019 1,176.7 / 4,568.9 = 25.8%; capital spending 375.9 / 45.8 = 8.2 times; peers 656.33 + 393.13 + 383.87 = 1,433.3, 1,433.3 / 245.24 = 5.8 times; FY2015 customers 15 + 12 + 11 = 38%. Process control segment gross margin FY2018 2,554.2 / 3,944.0 = 64.8%; FY2019 2,590.4 / 4,080.8 = 63.5%; FY2020 3,028.2 / 4,745.4 = 63.8%; FY2021 3,705.2 / 5,734.8 = 64.6%; FY2022 5,167.7 / 7,924.8 = 65.2%; FY2023 5,957.6 / 9,324.2 = 63.9%; FY2024 5,629.3 / 8,733.6 = 64.5%; FY2025 7,024.6 / 10,947.4 = 64.2%. Process control revenue FY2024 8,733.6 / 9,324.2 - 1 = -6.3%. Orbotech-related goodwill impairments 256.6 + 289.5 + 239.1 = 785.2. Research: 1,532.1 / 530.6 = 2.9 times; 530.6 / 2,814.0 = 18.9% (FY2015); 526.7 / 3,480.0 = 15.1% (FY2017); 711.0 / 4,568.9 = 15.6% (FY2019); 928.5 / 6,918.7 = 13.4% (FY2021); 1,296.7 / 10,496.1 = 12.4% (FY2023); 1,279.0 / 9,812.2 = 13.0% (FY2024); 1,532.1 / 13,579.5 = 11.3% (FY2026); FY2016 481.3 against 530.6 and FY2024 1,279.0 / 1,296.7 - 1 = -1.4%; research staff 27% x 17,000 = about 4,600. Product categories (FY2019-FY2026): wafer inspection 6,630.8 / 1,630.9 = 4.1 times, 22.2% a year; FY2025 6,198.8 / 4,333.3 - 1 = +43.1%; FY2026 6,630.8 / 6,198.8 - 1 = +7.0%; share 1,630.9 / 4,568.9 = 35.7% (FY2019), 6,198.8 / 12,156.2 = 51.0% (FY2025), 6,630.8 / 13,579.5 = 48.8% (FY2026). Patterning 2,706.8 / 1,161.3 = 2.3 times, 12.9% a year; FY2022 2,050.0 / 1,506.0 - 1 = +36.1%; FY2023 2,791.1 / 2,050.0 - 1 = +36.2%; FY2024 2,054.4 / 2,791.1 - 1 = -26.4%; FY2025 2,196.3 / 2,054.4 - 1 = +6.9%; FY2026 2,706.8 / 2,196.3 - 1 = +23.2%; share 2,791.1 / 10,496.1 = 26.6% (FY2023), 2,196.3 / 12,156.2 = 18.1% (FY2025), 2,706.8 / 13,579.5 = 19.9% (FY2026); process control lines 48.8 + 19.9 = 68.7%. SSP products 502.5 / 13,579.5 = 3.7%. PCI products 460.3 / 13,579.5 = 3.4%; FY2025 355.9 / 291.2 - 1 = +22.2%; FY2026 460.3 / 355.9 - 1 = +29.3%. Services 3,125.9 / 1,176.7 = 2.7 times, (3,125.9 / 1,176.7) ^ (1/7) - 1 = 15.0% a year; growth FY2020 +25.6%, FY2021 +13.6%, FY2022 +13.8%, FY2023 +10.8%, FY2024 2,329.6 / 2,117.0 - 1 = +10.0%, FY2025 +15.2%, FY2026 3,125.9 / 2,683.3 - 1 = +16.5%; FY2024 increase 2,329.6 - 2,117.0 = 212.6; share 2,117.0 / 10,496.1 = 20.2% (FY2023), 2,329.6 / 9,812.2 = 23.7% (FY2024), 3,125.9 / 13,579.5 = 23.0% (FY2026). Product revenue FY2023 10,496.1 - 2,117.0 = 8,379.1; FY2024 fall 8,379.1 - 7,482.7 = 896.4. A one-third fall in product revenue 10,453.5 / 3 = 3,484.5 against a year of 15% service growth 3,125.9 x 0.15 = 469, less than a seventh. Other 153.1 / 381.1 - 1 = -60%; 153.1 / 13,579.5 = 1.1%; FY2024 333.2 / 381.1 - 1 = -12.6%; FY2025 204.6 / 333.2 - 1 = -38.6%; FY2026 153.1 / 204.6 - 1 = -25.2%. Deferred system and service revenue 932.9 + 604.1 + 238.1 = 1,775.1, about $1.8 billion. Unrecognised contract price 1,775.1 / 3,125.9 x 12 = about 7 months of service revenue. Region: Taiwan FY2024 1,738.1 / 2,493.4 - 1 = -30.3%; FY2026 against FY2024 3,643.7 / 1,738.1 - 1 = +110%; FY2025 3,205.4 / 1,738.1 - 1 = +84.4%; FY2023 2,493.4 / 2,528.5 - 1 = -1.4%. Korea FY2019 584.1 / 1,178.6 - 1 = -50%; FY2024 906.9 / 1,895.7 - 1 = -52%; share 1,178.6 / 4,036.7 = 29.2% (FY2018), 584.1 / 4,568.9 = 12.8% (FY2019), 1,895.7 / 10,496.1 = 18.1% (FY2023), 906.9 / 9,812.2 = 9.2% (FY2024), 1,833.8 / 13,579.5 = 13.5% (FY2026). China FY2025 4,042.6 / 4,196.7 - 1 = -3.7%; FY2026 4,048.4 / 4,042.6 - 1 = +0.1%; China plus Taiwan 29.8% + 26.8% = 56.6%; Q4 FY2026 China 4,048.4 - 3,091.6 = 956.7, 956.7 / 3,657.6 = 26.2%. Backlog 12,570 / 7,860 - 1 = +59.9%; 12,570 / 13,579.5 = 93% of revenue; unrecognised contract price 1,775.1 / 12,570 = 14% of backlog. Advanced packaging about 1,000 / 13,579.5 = about 7% of revenue. Quarter: Q4 FY2026 revenue 3,657.6 / 3,174.7 - 1 = +15.2%; 3,657.6 / 3,415.1 - 1 = +7.1%; service 820.4 / 702.6 - 1 = +16.8%; process control 3,256.8 / 2,877.6 - 1 = +13.2%; PCB and Component Inspection 241.1 / 154.1 - 1 = +56.5%; GAAP gross margin (3,657.6 - 1,413.1) / 3,657.6 = 61.4%. Guidance midpoint 4,000 / 3,209.7 - 1 = +24.6%; 4,000 / 3,657.6 - 1 = +9.4%. Consensus fiscal 2027 18,110 / 13,579.5 - 1 = +33.4%; EPS 5.45 / 3.66 - 1 = +49%. The 2030 model at 13% a year: 13,579.5 x 1.13 ^ 2 = 17,340 (FY2028); 13,579.5 x 1.13 ^ 5 = about 25,000 (FY2031). Cash and capital: free cash flow 4,143.1 - 375.9 = 3,767.1; capital returns 2,289.8 + 1,057.8 = 3,347.6, 3,347.6 / 3,767.1 = 88.9%; dividends 1,057.8 / 4,830.8 = 21.9% of net income; buybacks 2,289.8 / 1,057.8 = 2.2 times dividends; capital spending 375.9 / 13,579.5 = 2.8% of revenue; operating cash flow 3,308.6 / 2,761.9 = 120% (FY2024), 4,081.9 / 4,061.6 = 100% (FY2025), 4,143.1 / 4,830.8 = 86% (FY2026); operating cash flow growth 4,143.1 / 4,081.9 - 1 = +1.5%; net income less operating cash flow 4,830.8 - 4,143.1 = 687.7; receivables 2,889.2 / 2,263.9 - 1 = +27.6%, an increase of 625.3; inventories 3,648.5 - 3,212.1 = 436.4; together 1,061.7. FY2015 dividends paid 3,041.1 / 366.2 = 8.3 times net income. Buybacks FY2015-FY2026 602.9 + 181.7 + 25.0 + 203.2 + 1,095.2 + 829.1 + 938.6 + 3,967.8 + 1,311.9 + 1,735.7 + 2,149.9 + 2,289.8 = 15,330.8; dividends paid 3,041.1 + 346.3 + 344.0 + 402.1 + 472.3 + 522.4 + 559.4 + 638.5 + 732.6 + 773.0 + 904.6 + 1,057.8 = 9,794.1. Diluted shares 1,319.6 / 1,637.0 - 1 = -19.4%. Net debt 5,887.4 - 1,649.8 - 3,252.6 = 985.0 (FY2026); 5,884.3 - 2,078.9 - 2,415.7 = 1,389.7 (FY2025); 6,630.1 - 1,977.1 - 2,526.9 = 2,126.1 (FY2024); 985.0 / 3,767.1 = 26% of free cash flow. Return on equity 4,830.8 / ((4,692.5 + 6,349.8) / 2 = 5,521.2) = 87.5%; FY2025 4,061.6 / ((3,368.3 + 4,692.5) / 2) = 100.8%; FY2024 2,761.9 / ((2,919.8 + 3,368.3) / 2) = 87.9%. Buyback authorisation 9,740 / 245,240 = 4%; 9,740 / (0.9 x 3,767.1) = 2.9 years; 9,740 / 571.0 = 17 quarters. Valuation: market value 245,240 / 383,870 = 0.64 (Applied Materials); 656,330 / 245,240 = 2.7 (ASML); 245,240 / 14,050 = 17.5 (Onto Innovation); 393,130 / 245,240 = 1.6 (Lam Research); 245,240 / 394,116 - 1 = -38% (June to September 2026); 394,116 / 118,454 = 3.3 times (June 2025 to June 2026); price 187.92 / 307.37 - 1 = -38.9%; 187.92 / 227.35 - 1 = -17% (June buyback price); 227.35 / 187.92 = 1.21 (21% more shares); free cash flow yield 3,767.1 / 245,240 = 1.5%; research 1,532.1 / 245,240 = 0.6% of KLA market value and 1,532.1 / 14,050 = 10.9%, about a ninth, of Onto Innovation's; revenue 13,579.5 / Lam Research 23,232.7 = 58%; market value 245,240 / 393,130 = 62%; buybacks 2,289.8 / 187.92 = 12.2 million shares at the September price, 12.2 / 1,319.6 = 0.9%; authorisation 9,740 / 2,289.8 = 4.3 years at the fiscal 2026 pace; P/E 245,240 / 4,830.8 = 50.8; P/S 245,240 / 13,579.5 = 18.1. Gross margin gap 61.3% less Lam Research about 50% = about 11 points - cash flow, capital returns, balance sheet, per-share figures and valuation. — FY2015-FY2026 · publ. September 2026 · source ↗
    Method: Arithmetic on figures reported in KLA's Forms 10-K and 10-Q, quarterly results releases, XBRL filings and market data; operands shown in the source line.
  2. ReportedKLA's equity was $1,401.4 million at the end of fiscal 2022, after $3,967.8 million of buybacks that year, and a return on that base would have been enormous whatever the business earned.
    SEC EDGAR XBRL company facts for KLA (CIK 319201) - revenue, cost of revenue, research and development, net income, diluted EPS and shares, operating cash flow, capital spending, buybacks, dividends, goodwill and equity for fiscal 2015-2026; per-share figures before fiscal 2024 are pre-split. — FY2015-FY2026 · publ. September 2026 · source ↗
  3. Moat Explorer calcReturn on invested capital by the repo method was 46.4% in fiscal 2026: still very high, and about half the return on equity.
    Moat Explorer calculation, repo method (tools_roic_edgar.py) on SEC EDGAR XBRL for CIK 319201: return on invested capital 13.0% (FY2015), 27.6%, 34.5%, 33.4%, 27.9%, 21.7%, 33.9%, 46.7%, 44.2%, 35.3%, 46.3%, 46.4% (FY2026). KLA tags no operating income after FY2014, so EBIT is pretax income plus interest expense (FY2026: 5,605.9 + 284.4 = 5,890.4); tax rate 775.2 / 5,605.9 = 13.8%; invested capital 11,996.8 (assets 17,951.5 - current liabilities 4,304.9 - cash 1,649.8) against 9,903.2 in FY2025; invested capital by year 2,986.2 (FY2015), 2,851.5, 3,086.0, 3,020.0 (FY2018), 6,224.0 (FY2019), 6,345.8, 6,733.3, 8,141.1, 8,401.6, 8,795.7, 9,903.2, 11,996.8. — FY2015-FY2026 · publ. September 2026 · source ↗
    Method: NOPAT (pretax income plus interest expense, times one minus the effective tax rate) divided by average operating invested capital (total assets less current liabilities less cash), from SEC EDGAR XBRL. Marketable securities ($3.25bn at June 2026) are not deducted, so the ratio is understated; EBIT includes other income and is after the goodwill impairments of FY2020, FY2024 and FY2025; the FY2018 tax rate is capped at 35%.
  4. ReportedBut it means the equity return will fall sharply in any year KLA stops buying back and lets equity rebuild, as it has since fiscal 2022, when equity went from $1,401.4 million to $6,349.8 million.
    SEC EDGAR XBRL company facts for KLA (CIK 319201) - revenue, cost of revenue, research and development, net income, diluted EPS and shares, operating cash flow, capital spending, buybacks, dividends, goodwill and equity for fiscal 2015-2026; per-share figures before fiscal 2024 are pre-split. — FY2015-FY2026 · publ. September 2026 · source ↗
  5. ReportedBut it means the equity return will fall sharply in any year KLA stops buying back and lets equity rebuild, as it has since fiscal 2022, when equity went from $1,401.4 million to $6,349.8 million.
    KLA Corporation Form 10-K for fiscal 2026 (year ended 30 June 2026) - financial statements and notes: backlog, contract liabilities, receivables, cash flow, capital returns and debt. — FY2026 · publ. 6 August 2026 · source ↗
  6. ReportedStockanalysis puts KLA's return on invested capital at 66.75%, higher than the repo method's 46.4%, because it measures capital differently.
    KLA (KLAC) statistics - return on equity 87.50%, return on invested capital 66.75%, effective tax rate 13.83%, operating margin 41.69%, FCF margin 27.74%, short interest 23.55 million shares (1.80%). — September 2026 · publ. 25 September 2026 · source ↗
  7. Moat Explorer calcStockanalysis puts KLA's return on invested capital at 66.75%, higher than the repo method's 46.4%, because it measures capital differently.
    Moat Explorer calculation, repo method (tools_roic_edgar.py) on SEC EDGAR XBRL for CIK 319201: return on invested capital 13.0% (FY2015), 27.6%, 34.5%, 33.4%, 27.9%, 21.7%, 33.9%, 46.7%, 44.2%, 35.3%, 46.3%, 46.4% (FY2026). KLA tags no operating income after FY2014, so EBIT is pretax income plus interest expense (FY2026: 5,605.9 + 284.4 = 5,890.4); tax rate 775.2 / 5,605.9 = 13.8%; invested capital 11,996.8 (assets 17,951.5 - current liabilities 4,304.9 - cash 1,649.8) against 9,903.2 in FY2025; invested capital by year 2,986.2 (FY2015), 2,851.5, 3,086.0, 3,020.0 (FY2018), 6,224.0 (FY2019), 6,345.8, 6,733.3, 8,141.1, 8,401.6, 8,795.7, 9,903.2, 11,996.8. — FY2015-FY2026 · publ. September 2026 · source ↗
    Method: NOPAT (pretax income plus interest expense, times one minus the effective tax rate) divided by average operating invested capital (total assets less current liabilities less cash), from SEC EDGAR XBRL. Marketable securities ($3.25bn at June 2026) are not deducted, so the ratio is understated; EBIT includes other income and is after the goodwill impairments of FY2020, FY2024 and FY2025; the FY2018 tax rate is capped at 35%.
  8. ReportedKLA traded at 38.68 times book value on 25 September 2026, a multiple that says more about how little equity is left than about how richly the shares are priced.
    KLA (KLAC) statistics - return on equity 87.50%, return on invested capital 66.75%, effective tax rate 13.83%, operating margin 41.69%, FCF margin 27.74%, short interest 23.55 million shares (1.80%). — September 2026 · publ. 25 September 2026 · source ↗
Sources
Generated September 28, 2026