OPACC: The Capital Charge Caterpillar Sets ItselfWide moat

Caterpillar (CAT) — moat facet

Caterpillar's manufacturing business earned about 53% pre-tax on its net assets in 2025, four times the 13% charge it sets itself.

Caterpillar judges its businesses with its own yardstick, and the yardstick shows how profitable the manufacturing business is once the finance arm is set aside. Operating profit after capital charge, or OPACC, subtracts a 13% pre-tax charge on average net assets of the machinery, power and energy business from its adjusted operating profit1.

Pre-tax return on average MP&E net assets (%)23.3202032.8202143.6202269.1202366.2202452.92025Calculated from the OPACC reconciliation, Caterpillar Barclays deck, Feb 2026
Far above the 13% charge in every year.

The inputs are published. Average MP&E net assets were $19,450 million in 2023, $19,999 million in 2024 and $21,417 million in 2025, against MP&E adjusted operating profit of $13,439 million, $13,246 million and $11,327 million2. That is a pre-tax return on net assets of about 69%, 66% and 53%3, against the 13% charge.

Total enterprise OPACC was $2,066 million in 2020, $10,911 million in 2023 and $8,544 million in 20254. Caterpillar ties its incentive pay to it and says OPACC growth since 2020 was 4.1 times5.

The reason the numbers are so high is that the net asset base is small. Dealers hold the inventory that customers see, suppliers fund part of the rest, and the long-term receivables sit with Cat Financial. Manufacturing capital of about $21 billion produced about $11 billion of pre-tax operating profit in 20256.

The measure matters inside the company. Caterpillar says there is a strong correlation between OPACC dollar growth and shareholder returns, and reports top-quartile five-year total shareholder return against the S&P 500 capital goods index7. A company that pays its managers on returns above a capital charge is less likely to buy growth at any price.

This is the strongest evidence of a moat in Caterpillar's numbers, and it is measured by the company, which is its weakness. The pre-tax return on MP&E net assets fell from about 69% in 2023 to about 53% in 20258; a further fall toward 30% in a year of record sales would say the extra volume is being bought with capital.

Moat trajectory: Narrowing

Pre-tax return on MP&E net assets about 69% in 2023, 53% in 2025.

The number that tests this moat
Moat Explorer calc
Pre-tax return on MP&E net assets
About 53% (2025) against a 13% capital charge; 66% in 2024

Caterpillar's own capital test; a fall toward 30% in a record year would mean volume is being bought with capital.

How it's calculated: MP&E adjusted operating profit divided by average MP&E net assets, from the OPACC reconciliation in Caterpillar's February 2026 Barclays deck: 11,327 / 21,417 (2025), 13,246 / 19,999 (2024).
Source: Moat Explorer calculation from Caterpillar filings ↗
⚠ Threats to the moat
⚠ THREAT 01
A Yardstick the Company Defines
Caterpillar's favourite measure adds back restructuring charges it records almost every year.
References
  1. ReportedOperating profit after capital charge, or OPACC, subtracts a 13% pre-tax charge on average net assets of the machinery, power and energy business from its adjusted operating profit.
    Caterpillar presentation for the Barclays fireside chat, 18 February 2026 - Investor Day targets, services, MP&E free cash flow, share count, buyback prices and the OPACC reconciliation. — 2019-2025 · publ. 18 February 2026 · source ↗
  2. ReportedAverage MP&E net assets were $19,450 million in 2023, $19,999 million in 2024 and $21,417 million in 2025, against MP&E adjusted operating profit of $13,439 million, $13,246 million and $11,327 million.
    Caterpillar presentation for the Barclays fireside chat, 18 February 2026 - Investor Day targets, services, MP&E free cash flow, share count, buyback prices and the OPACC reconciliation. — 2019-2025 · publ. 18 February 2026 · source ↗
  3. Moat Explorer calcThat is a pre-tax return on net assets of about 69%, 66% and 53%, against the 13% charge.
    Moat Explorer calculation from Caterpillar's reported figures ($ millions unless stated). Dealers: 41 + 109 = 150 (2025); 43 + 113 = 156 (2022); 46 + 119 = 165 (2019). Segment margins (segment profit / total segment sales, FY2025 10-K basis): Construction Industries 6,975 / 27,418 = 25.4% (2023), 6,165 / 25,455 = 24.2% (2024), 4,675 / 25,060 = 18.7% (2025); Resource Industries 2,836 / 13,669 = 20.7%, 2,538 / 12,471 = 20.4%, 1,988 / 12,474 = 15.9%; Power & Energy 4,936 / 28,001 = 17.6%, 5,736 / 28,854 = 19.9%, 6,418 / 32,201 = 19.9%; Financial Products 909 / 3,785 = 24.0%, 932 / 4,053 = 23.0%, 966 / 4,220 = 22.9%, 590 / 3,044 = 19.4% (2020). Recast (Rail in Resource Industries): 2,151 / 15,920 = 13.5% (2025), 2,676 / 15,745 = 17.0% (2024); Power & Energy 6,256 / 28,624 = 21.9%. Construction Industries H1 2026 3,482 / 15,507 = 22.5%. Implied Rail: sales 15,920 - 12,474 = 3,446 and profit 2,151 - 1,988 = 163, 163 / 3,446 = 4.7% (2025); sales 15,745 - 12,471 = 3,274 and profit 2,676 - 2,538 = 138 (2024). Power generation 10,275 / 3,963 = 2.6 times (2020-2025); 10,275 / 67,589 = 15.2% of sales and revenues; three times the 2024 base 7,756 x 3 = 23,268. Oil and gas 7,502 / 27,143 = 27.6% of Power & Energy external sales; 7,502 / 3,701 = 2.0 times. Services 24 / 67.589 = 35.5%; (30 / 24)^(1/5) - 1 = 4.6% a year. Backlog 72.1 / 30.0 = 2.4 times; long end 29.2 / 19.3 - 1 = 51%. Customer advances 4,777 / 3,314 - 1 = 44%. Price realization H1 2026 426 + 595 = 1,021; 2024 against 2023 1,238 / 5,596 = 22%. Volume H1 2026 2,318 + 3,113 = 5,431. Capex excluding leased equipment 2,821 / 1,597 - 1 = 77%. Pre-tax return on average MP&E net assets (MP&E adjusted operating profit / average MP&E net assets): 4,675 / 20,070 = 23.3% (2020), 6,453 / 19,662 = 32.8% (2021), 8,656 / 19,841 = 43.6% (2022), 13,439 / 19,450 = 69.1% (2023), 13,246 / 19,999 = 66.2% (2024), 11,327 / 21,417 = 52.9% (2025). Profit 8,884 / 6,147 - 1 = 44.5% and diluted EPS 18.81 / 10.26 - 1 = 83.3% (2018-2025). Dividends paid 2,749 / profit 8,884 = 30.9%. Return on average equity 8,884 / ((19,494 + 21,318) / 2) = 43.5%. Price to earnings at year end (market capitalisation $bn / profit $bn): 39.57 / 2.512 = 15.8 (2015); 93.75 / 0.754 = 124.3 (2017); 74.98 / 6.147 = 12.2 (2018); 81.62 / 6.093 = 13.4 (2019); 98.88 / 2.998 = 33.0 (2020); 111.83 / 6.489 = 17.2 (2021); 124.67 / 6.705 = 18.6 (2022); 150.52 / 10.335 = 14.6 (2023); 175.14 / 10.792 = 16.2 (2024); 268.09 / 8.884 = 30.2 (2025); trailing 370.15 / 10.844 = 34.1. Share price 805.25 / 1,073.46 - 1 = -25%. Trailing twelve months to June 2026: sales and revenues 67,589 - 30,818 + 37,958 = 74,729; profit 8,884 - 4,182 + 6,142 = 10,844; diluted EPS 18.81 - 8.82 + 13.23 = 23.22. Debt at 30 June 2026 5,046 + 35 + 8,026 + 10,655 + 21,384 = 45,146; at 31 December 2025 5,514 + 35 + 7,085 + 10,678 + 20,018 = 43,330; Financial Products debt 5,514 + 7,085 + 20,018 = 32,617, 32,617 / 43,330 = 75%. Financial Products segment assets 41,476 / 64,392 = 64%. Downturns: 38,537 / 47,011 - 1 = -18% (2016); 41,748 / 53,800 - 1 = -22% (2020). Construction Industries Asia/Pacific external sales 3,783 / 4,390 - 1 = -14%; North America share 14,064 / 24,800 = 57%. Shares of 2025 sales and revenues of 67,589: Construction Industries 24,800 = 36.7%; Resource Industries 12,185 = 18.0%; Power & Energy 27,143 = 40.2%; Financial Products 4,220 = 6.2%; Construction and Resource together (24,800 + 12,185) / 67,589 = 54.7%. Segment external sum 27,143 + 24,800 + 12,185 + 4,220 = 68,348 against 67,589 (difference 759, All Other +46 and corporate items -805); 2024 25,344 + 12,100 + 24,088 + 4,053 = 65,585 against 64,809 (776); 2023 27,294 + 13,329 + 23,355 + 3,785 = 67,763 against 67,060 (703). Power & Energy share 27,143 / 68,348 = 39.7%. 2030 range: 64,809 x 1.06^6 = 91,933; 64,809 x 1.09^6 = 108,691. RPMGlobal 733 / 67,589 = 1.1%. Autonomous trucks 827 / 690 - 1 = 20%; 690 x 3 = 2,070. Tech-enabled machines 500 / 191 = 2.6 times. Latin America employees 22,300 - 19,700 = 2,600 (EAME 16,700 - 15,900 = 800; Asia/Pacific 26,900 - 25,300 = 1,600; North America 52,100 - 52,000 = 100). Profit 2025 8,884 / 10,792 - 1 = -17.7%. Cost of goods sold 44,752 / 40,199 - 1 = 11.3%. Financial Products segment assets 41,476 / 36,925 - 1 = 12.3%. Power generation growth 7,756 / 6,362 - 1 = 21.9%, 10,275 / 7,756 - 1 = 32.5%. Engine capex at 4% to 5% of 2025 machinery, power and energy sales of 63,980: 2,559 to 3,199. Earnings implied by forward and trailing P/E 34.70 / 28.01 - 1 = 24%. Analyst target 975.61 / 805.25 - 1 = 21%. Segment capex 2025: Construction Industries 358 + Resource Industries 626 = 984, against Financial Products 1,341. Power & Energy Q2 2026 external sales: North America 4,182 against other regions 373 + 1,348 + 892 = 2,613 - valuation, balance sheet, capital returns and returns on capital. — 2015-2026 · publ. September 2026 · source ↗
    Method: Arithmetic on figures reported in Caterpillar's Forms 10-K, 10-Q, results releases, the March 2026 recast exhibit, the February 2026 Barclays deck, the earnings calls and market data; operands shown in the source line.
  4. ReportedTotal enterprise OPACC was $2,066 million in 2020, $10,911 million in 2023 and $8,544 million in 2025.
    Caterpillar presentation for the Barclays fireside chat, 18 February 2026 - Investor Day targets, services, MP&E free cash flow, share count, buyback prices and the OPACC reconciliation. — 2019-2025 · publ. 18 February 2026 · source ↗
  5. ReportedCaterpillar ties its incentive pay to it and says OPACC growth since 2020 was 4.1 times.
    Caterpillar presentation for the Barclays fireside chat, 18 February 2026 - Investor Day targets, services, MP&E free cash flow, share count, buyback prices and the OPACC reconciliation. — 2019-2025 · publ. 18 February 2026 · source ↗
  6. ReportedManufacturing capital of about $21 billion produced about $11 billion of pre-tax operating profit in 2025.
    Caterpillar presentation for the Barclays fireside chat, 18 February 2026 - Investor Day targets, services, MP&E free cash flow, share count, buyback prices and the OPACC reconciliation. — 2019-2025 · publ. 18 February 2026 · source ↗
  7. ReportedCaterpillar says there is a strong correlation between OPACC dollar growth and shareholder returns, and reports top-quartile five-year total shareholder return against the S&P 500 capital goods index.
    Caterpillar presentation for the Barclays fireside chat, 18 February 2026 - Investor Day targets, services, MP&E free cash flow, share count, buyback prices and the OPACC reconciliation. — 2019-2025 · publ. 18 February 2026 · source ↗
  8. Moat Explorer calcThe pre-tax return on MP&E net assets fell from about 69% in 2023 to about 53% in 2025; a further fall toward 30% in a year of record sales would say the extra volume is being bought with capital.
    Moat Explorer calculation from Caterpillar's reported figures ($ millions unless stated). Dealers: 41 + 109 = 150 (2025); 43 + 113 = 156 (2022); 46 + 119 = 165 (2019). Segment margins (segment profit / total segment sales, FY2025 10-K basis): Construction Industries 6,975 / 27,418 = 25.4% (2023), 6,165 / 25,455 = 24.2% (2024), 4,675 / 25,060 = 18.7% (2025); Resource Industries 2,836 / 13,669 = 20.7%, 2,538 / 12,471 = 20.4%, 1,988 / 12,474 = 15.9%; Power & Energy 4,936 / 28,001 = 17.6%, 5,736 / 28,854 = 19.9%, 6,418 / 32,201 = 19.9%; Financial Products 909 / 3,785 = 24.0%, 932 / 4,053 = 23.0%, 966 / 4,220 = 22.9%, 590 / 3,044 = 19.4% (2020). Recast (Rail in Resource Industries): 2,151 / 15,920 = 13.5% (2025), 2,676 / 15,745 = 17.0% (2024); Power & Energy 6,256 / 28,624 = 21.9%. Construction Industries H1 2026 3,482 / 15,507 = 22.5%. Implied Rail: sales 15,920 - 12,474 = 3,446 and profit 2,151 - 1,988 = 163, 163 / 3,446 = 4.7% (2025); sales 15,745 - 12,471 = 3,274 and profit 2,676 - 2,538 = 138 (2024). Power generation 10,275 / 3,963 = 2.6 times (2020-2025); 10,275 / 67,589 = 15.2% of sales and revenues; three times the 2024 base 7,756 x 3 = 23,268. Oil and gas 7,502 / 27,143 = 27.6% of Power & Energy external sales; 7,502 / 3,701 = 2.0 times. Services 24 / 67.589 = 35.5%; (30 / 24)^(1/5) - 1 = 4.6% a year. Backlog 72.1 / 30.0 = 2.4 times; long end 29.2 / 19.3 - 1 = 51%. Customer advances 4,777 / 3,314 - 1 = 44%. Price realization H1 2026 426 + 595 = 1,021; 2024 against 2023 1,238 / 5,596 = 22%. Volume H1 2026 2,318 + 3,113 = 5,431. Capex excluding leased equipment 2,821 / 1,597 - 1 = 77%. Pre-tax return on average MP&E net assets (MP&E adjusted operating profit / average MP&E net assets): 4,675 / 20,070 = 23.3% (2020), 6,453 / 19,662 = 32.8% (2021), 8,656 / 19,841 = 43.6% (2022), 13,439 / 19,450 = 69.1% (2023), 13,246 / 19,999 = 66.2% (2024), 11,327 / 21,417 = 52.9% (2025). Profit 8,884 / 6,147 - 1 = 44.5% and diluted EPS 18.81 / 10.26 - 1 = 83.3% (2018-2025). Dividends paid 2,749 / profit 8,884 = 30.9%. Return on average equity 8,884 / ((19,494 + 21,318) / 2) = 43.5%. Price to earnings at year end (market capitalisation $bn / profit $bn): 39.57 / 2.512 = 15.8 (2015); 93.75 / 0.754 = 124.3 (2017); 74.98 / 6.147 = 12.2 (2018); 81.62 / 6.093 = 13.4 (2019); 98.88 / 2.998 = 33.0 (2020); 111.83 / 6.489 = 17.2 (2021); 124.67 / 6.705 = 18.6 (2022); 150.52 / 10.335 = 14.6 (2023); 175.14 / 10.792 = 16.2 (2024); 268.09 / 8.884 = 30.2 (2025); trailing 370.15 / 10.844 = 34.1. Share price 805.25 / 1,073.46 - 1 = -25%. Trailing twelve months to June 2026: sales and revenues 67,589 - 30,818 + 37,958 = 74,729; profit 8,884 - 4,182 + 6,142 = 10,844; diluted EPS 18.81 - 8.82 + 13.23 = 23.22. Debt at 30 June 2026 5,046 + 35 + 8,026 + 10,655 + 21,384 = 45,146; at 31 December 2025 5,514 + 35 + 7,085 + 10,678 + 20,018 = 43,330; Financial Products debt 5,514 + 7,085 + 20,018 = 32,617, 32,617 / 43,330 = 75%. Financial Products segment assets 41,476 / 64,392 = 64%. Downturns: 38,537 / 47,011 - 1 = -18% (2016); 41,748 / 53,800 - 1 = -22% (2020). Construction Industries Asia/Pacific external sales 3,783 / 4,390 - 1 = -14%; North America share 14,064 / 24,800 = 57%. Shares of 2025 sales and revenues of 67,589: Construction Industries 24,800 = 36.7%; Resource Industries 12,185 = 18.0%; Power & Energy 27,143 = 40.2%; Financial Products 4,220 = 6.2%; Construction and Resource together (24,800 + 12,185) / 67,589 = 54.7%. Segment external sum 27,143 + 24,800 + 12,185 + 4,220 = 68,348 against 67,589 (difference 759, All Other +46 and corporate items -805); 2024 25,344 + 12,100 + 24,088 + 4,053 = 65,585 against 64,809 (776); 2023 27,294 + 13,329 + 23,355 + 3,785 = 67,763 against 67,060 (703). Power & Energy share 27,143 / 68,348 = 39.7%. 2030 range: 64,809 x 1.06^6 = 91,933; 64,809 x 1.09^6 = 108,691. RPMGlobal 733 / 67,589 = 1.1%. Autonomous trucks 827 / 690 - 1 = 20%; 690 x 3 = 2,070. Tech-enabled machines 500 / 191 = 2.6 times. Latin America employees 22,300 - 19,700 = 2,600 (EAME 16,700 - 15,900 = 800; Asia/Pacific 26,900 - 25,300 = 1,600; North America 52,100 - 52,000 = 100). Profit 2025 8,884 / 10,792 - 1 = -17.7%. Cost of goods sold 44,752 / 40,199 - 1 = 11.3%. Financial Products segment assets 41,476 / 36,925 - 1 = 12.3%. Power generation growth 7,756 / 6,362 - 1 = 21.9%, 10,275 / 7,756 - 1 = 32.5%. Engine capex at 4% to 5% of 2025 machinery, power and energy sales of 63,980: 2,559 to 3,199. Earnings implied by forward and trailing P/E 34.70 / 28.01 - 1 = 24%. Analyst target 975.61 / 805.25 - 1 = 21%. Segment capex 2025: Construction Industries 358 + Resource Industries 626 = 984, against Financial Products 1,341. Power & Energy Q2 2026 external sales: North America 4,182 against other regions 373 + 1,348 + 892 = 2,613 - valuation, balance sheet, capital returns and returns on capital. — 2015-2026 · publ. September 2026 · source ↗
    Method: Arithmetic on figures reported in Caterpillar's Forms 10-K, 10-Q, results releases, the March 2026 recast exhibit, the February 2026 Barclays deck, the earnings calls and market data; operands shown in the source line.
Sources
Generated September 25, 2026